Two exes dating siblings and spending the holidays together… what could go wrong? Well, according to the newly released Our Little Secret trailer, everything that could go wrong will go wrong.

Lindsay Lohan headlines the Netflix original Christmas romantic comedy as Avery, who spends the holidays with her boyfriend Cameron (Jon Rudnitsky). However, once she begins to meet his family, she discovers that her boyfriend’s sister is dating her ex-boyfriend, Logan (Ian Harding). In order to avoid causing drama, Avery and Logan decide to keep their past a secret.

As the trailer reveals, 10 years prior to dating siblings, Logan had gotten down on one knee and proposed to Avery. Unfortunately for him, she turned down his proposal in front of a whole crowd. More than likely, that’s where their relationship turned sour and caused them to be “resentful exes,” as the movie’s synopsis teases. An awkward proposal will definitely do that!